More

    “The Middle is Very Seductive”: Inside Menswear’s Value Shift

    Image may contain Son Hoyeong Clothing Coat Adult Person Overcoat Fashion Face and Head
    Photo: Courtesy of Sage Nation

    Timothy Grindle, the founder of Canoe Club, a menswear store in Boulder, Colorado, keeps a list on his phone that tracks all the brands he’s considering buying. “I put them in different categories: one is ‘soon’, one is ‘keep an eye on it’, and the last one is brands that nobody knows about yet,” he says. “I shift them around until I feel like we’re ready to stock them or they start to fill a gap that we might have.”

    In recent seasons, Grindle’s buy at Canoe Club has moved away from “traditional runway brands” into independent labels like Seya, Taiga Takahashi, and Aaron Levine. “Legacy brands are not the ones that are leading for us at all; it’s a collective of a lot of the smaller brands,” he says. The shift is buoying Canoe Club’s business: this year, the store is moving to a larger site in a former peanut butter factory, expanding its stock and hiring more staff, which Grindle says is the result of the boom in smaller brands. “It used to be a real risk to bring in new stuff, but not anymore. People have never been this open to new brands.” The labels resonating with Grindle’s customers share similar priorities: a focus on fabric development and manufacturing.

    Image may contain Son Hoyeong Person Black Hair Hair Clothing Pants Face and Head

    Sage Nation AW25.

    Photo: Courtesy of Sage Nation

    With soaring prices in high fashion and eroding trust in fast fashion and mass-market basics, brands that prioritize craft and fabric are well-positioned to capture market share because they offer a convincing balance of quality, originality, and fair prices. “People are turned off by both extremes for different reasons,” says menswear journalist Louis Cheslaw, who writes the Wardrobe newsletter on Substack. A £500 shirt from Japanese brand Kaptain Sunshine, for instance, may still be expensive, but it doesn’t feel like a rip-off. “You do get your money’s worth in the middle ground, because the fabric feels incredible. It’s very seductive,” he says.

    Gregory Hewitt, who runs the London-based showroom DMSR, stocks brands like Kartik Research and Sage Nation, which have seen a consistent uptick in sales over the past few seasons. “There is a higher demand for brands that are known for craft and design, and we’re seeing solid growth across those brands for sure,” he says, adding that buyers want both authenticity and brands that don’t feel like anything else.

    Image may contain Formal Wear Accessories Tie Clothing Suit Adult Person Head Face and Necktie

    Carter Young deadstock virgin wool suit, shirt and tie.

    Photo: Courtesy of Carter Young

    The rise of the menswear hobbyist

    According to Cheslaw, the booming interest around these fabric-focused labels is simple: it’s reflective of what people are actually wearing. “I’ve interviewed hundreds of men at this point, and not a single one has said ‘I’m wearing the new Dior’,” he says.

    Instead, data shows that men are becoming more fastidious about the background and quality of the clothes they buy. According to a 2026 consumer survey by Euromonitor, 39% of global male respondents said they extensively researched the products and services they consume, while 36% said they were willing to pay more for more durable, higher-quality fashion purchases.

    For stores, the hyper-informed, hardcore enthusiast customer can pose a challenge. “The guys that are deeply into this stuff are, in the most complimentary way, huge nerds, and there’s been like a bit of a veil pulled where the customer is really intelligent now,” says Grindle. With nearly a decade in business, the store owner used to feel like he knew more than his customers. “Now, dude, I’m keeping up.”

    To keep on top of evolving tastes, Canoe Club has refined its online strategy. The store runs a YouTube channel where staff walk viewers through brands and also runs an active Discord channel to cultivate an online community among its customers, who use it to share fashion tips and nerd out about brands. The platform also provides a fruitful resource for Grindle to tap into the menswear hive mind and inform his list — and thus what eventually makes it to the shop floor.

    Designers also have to find new ways to connect and impress. Evan Kinori, the San Francisco-based designer known for earthy-looking fabrics that he develops mostly in Japan, details the entire process on his website — as well as educating his customers, it also helps justify his prices. “I think clients deserve to know what had to take place to get that object in front of them, and also what informs the price,” he says.

    Image may contain Adult Person Cooking Food Stirring Food and Meal

    Evan Kinori’s manufacturing process in Japan.

    Photo: Courtesy of Evan Kinori

    The right retail response

    At Shop Boswell in Portland, Oregon, owner Brookes Boswell is adding to her selection of independent menswear brands; this season, they account for 40-45% of her buy, and she expects this to rise to half once the summer buying season closes. “I’m seeing more, especially younger men, who are interested in fashion in general. It’s like a hobby,” says Boswell.

    To get their attention, Boswell says that putting a heavy focus on quality alone is not enough; it’s fit and size grading that are most crucial when cinching a sale. “It doesn’t matter how many times it’s been dipped in the mud bath or how many threads per inch it’s been woven, it still has to fit really well,” she says, singling out Kaptain Sunshine, Arpenteur, and Camiel Fortgens as brands that excel at both fit and fabric.

    Image may contain Accessories Bag Handbag Furniture Indoors Clothing Footwear Shoe Hat Closet and Dressing Room

    Shop Boswell store in Portland, Oregon.

    Photo: Courtesy of Shop Boswell

    The shift is also influencing how luxury stores are merchandising collections: Kartik Research and Sage Nation now hang in the designer rooms at department stores like Selfridges and Liberty, where they sit next to Dries van Noten and Lemaire — brands that, by and large, command a much higher price point. (A cotton shirt from Kartik Research costs £325 from Selfridges, while a comparable style at Dries van Noten is £945.) “The fabrics and designs of these brands stand up against all the more established brands, and the sell-throughs prove it,” says Hewitt.

    To keep the momentum going, experts say that brands need to watch closely what’s selling and be unafraid to lean into it. “You don’t have to reinvent the wheel every season, especially if it’s a hit,” says Hewitt. “If a buyer has great success with one style of shirt or pants, they are happy to buy again in a new fabric or color.”

    “To get someone to purchase your version of a product, you need to tell a wider narrative that is relevant to them and represents them on some deeper level,” says Altman. Last year, the brand launched a made-to-measure service, which the designer says has been the fastest growing area of the business “by leaps and bounds”.

    The brand has also made a concerted push to dress directors and performers, and collaborated with stylist Patricia Villirillo on a capsule collection last year, which Altman says was a resounding success. “I think we connect with our consumer because we’re talking to a contemporary cultural landscape that they are also participating in and trying to make something that’s not just reverential to the past, but relevant for now,” he says.

    Kinori, for his part, takes a more hermit-like approach. “I try to turn down all the noise and stay in tune with my own frequency,” he says. “Maybe one day everyone will be wearing skintight stretch denim or polyester jumpsuits and my work will be irrelevant, but I’ll still be approaching it just as I am now.”

     

    Latest articles

    spot_imgspot_img

    Related articles