More

    Are Ergonomic Office Chairs Just a Scam?

    Do you use an ergonomic office chair? If so, do you sit in it the way people do in the marketing materials, or do you find yourself slouching forward throughout the day? Despite repeatedly forcing myself to press my lower back into my chair’s lumbar support and sit up straight, as soon as I start to focus on the work, I begin to slouch. Is that my fault, the chair’s, or the very act of sitting? Musculoskeletal radiologist Dr. Waseem Bashir did a seating position study at the University of Aberdeen. Dr. Bashir used a positional MRI machine—that’s an MRI machine that you can actually sit down inside of—to examine the spines of 22 people with no history of back pain, sitting in three different positions: Straight-backed at 90 degrees, slouched forward, and reclining back at 135 degrees.By examining the sitter’s discs in all three positions, Dr. Bashir found that the slouched position compressed the discs into the worst position. Slouched The second worst was the 90-degree position. “I know we’ve always been told to sit upright with our backs straight, but our study shows that this position is not naturally favorable for your back at all,” Dr. Bashir said.Sitting up straight at 90 degreesAs for why: The discs in our backs actually contain water, which helps them maintain their thickness and spread the load. When we compress our discs, the water gets squeezed out into surrounding tissue. Once we remove that load—say, by lying down—the water flows back into the disc, rehydrating it. But ideally we would not regularly cause the water loss in the first place.”We’ve shown that even within a 10 minute period sitting in these postures, forward slouched and at 90 degrees, you already start seeing signs of water loss in the discs,” says Dr. Bashir. “Just think of that day in day out, year in year out, you will eventually cause degeneration because you’re in a posture that your body doesn’t like.”And why does sitting up straight eventually lead to slouching? “When you’re sitting at 90 degrees, that’s not natural,” Dr. Bashir explains, “because your knees are up and your back’s straight, so you’re actually pushing against gravity. Your abdominals are doing a lot of work trying to keep you straight, that’s why you end up getting tired and you slouch forward.”In contrast, the 135-degree reclining position was the best for the subjects’ discs, “placing very little strain on the spinal discs and associated musculature.” Alas, few office set-ups have you working in that position. “The bottom line is that we don’t have any [work] chairs available to us that are appropriate for the best sitting position,” Dr. Bashir concluded.Reclined at 135 degrees Dr. Bashir suggested that data from positional MRI machines should be used to design better seating. It fell on deaf ears. Dr. Bashir’s study was done 20 years ago, in 2006, and no one has paid attention. Except, perhaps, German product designer Paul Weatherstone. After reading the study, he puts things bluntly: “The upright office chair is built around a posture almost nobody holds,” he writes. “The upright 90-degree posture — back vertical, thighs horizontal, feet flat — is the shape office chairs are built around and the shape almost nobody keeps for more than a few minutes.”Weatherstone decided to do something about it. We’ll look at that next. 

    Latest articles

    spot_imgspot_img

    Related articles